Quora:印度若用布拉莫斯导弹打击中国,中国会如何?

2019.7.8 发布在 世界看中国 栏目

Quora:印度若用布拉莫斯导弹打击中国,中国会如何? 世界看中国-第1张

If India strikes China with multiple BrahMos missiles,what will China do?
如果印度用多枚布拉莫斯导弹袭击中国,中国会怎么做?
以下是QuOra读者的评论:
Nithin S,Educator(2017-present)

Brahmos is a super Sonic cruise missile developed by both India and Russia.Once Brahmos is fired the enemies doesn’t even get time to initiate counter strike.Brahmos travels at speed of Mach 2.7-3.0 and it also has multiple guidance system making it hard for the enemies to jam Brahmos.It doesn’t move in straight lines so radar can’t intercept these missiles.
There is only one defence systems,the Barak 8 that can have chances to defend against Brahmos.But it’s only in chances,not proven yet.
布拉莫斯导弹是印度和俄罗斯共同研制的一种超音速巡航导弹。一旦布拉莫斯被发射,敌人甚至没有时间发起反击。布拉莫斯的飞行速度为2.7-3.0马赫,它还有多个制导系统,使得敌人很难干扰布拉莫斯。它不会直线移动,所以雷达无法拦截这些导弹。
只有一种防御系统,巴拉克8号有机会对抗布拉莫斯。但这只是有可能,还未得到证实。

Nithin S,Educator(2017-present)

From land based launching pads it’s not feasible.But from air brahmos can hit anywhere inchina.Eventhough it’s an anti-ship cruise missile.The Brahmos block IⅢ can hit land based targets also.
Brahmos,the world’s fastest cruise missile jointly developed by India and Russia.It has a range of 300km and a speed of 3,400km/h-3,700km/h.Eventhough it is fastest missiles in the world it lacks range.With the 300km Brahmos block IIⅢ can’t hit any major parts of China.It’s 300km range can cover targets somewhere along the India China border.
从陆基发射台发射是不可能实现的。但是从空中发射的话,布拉莫斯导弹可以打到中国的任何地方。尽管它是一种反舰巡航导弹。布拉莫斯blockI也能命中地面目标。
布拉莫斯导弹是世界上最快的巡航导弹,由印度和俄罗斯联合研发。它的射程为300公里,速度为3,400公里/小时—3,700公里/小时。尽管它是世界上速度最快的导弹,但它缺射程太小。布拉莫斯blockIm的射程仅为300公里,无法袭击中国任何关键地区。300公里的射程只能覆盖到中印边界。

Brahmos was developed when India was not a member of MTCR(missile technology control regime).So Russian can’t jointly develop missiles with any non MTCR nations.If they had to,the limit cannot exceed 300km.That’s why current range of Brahmos is 300km.
Now India decided to induct Brahoms into SU 30 MKL.Integration of Brahmos into SU 30MKI gives it a range of 800km and it can strike anywhere in china including China’s major parts.
With its multiple guidance system like GPS,INS,GLONASS makes it very hard for china to jam Brahmos.And moreover Brahmos doesn’t travel in straight line,so it can’t intercept by defence systems.
Now India and Russia decided to increase it range from the existing 300 km to 600km.And the second version of Brahmos is hyper sonic
布拉莫斯导弹是在印度还不是MTCR(号弹技术控制制度)成员国时研发的。俄罗斯不能与任何非MTCR国家联合开发导弹。如果必须研发,射程也不能超过300公里。这就是布拉莫斯目前的射程仅有300公里的原因。
现在印度决定将布拉莫斯导装配在苏30MKI上。布拉莫斯导弹与苏30MKI导弹的结合使其射程达到800公里,可以攻击中国任何地方,包括中国的关键地区。因为拥有GPS、INS等多种导航系统,中国很难干扰布拉莫斯。而且布拉莫斯导弹不是直线飞行的,所以也不会被中国防御系统拦截。
现在,印度和俄罗斯决定将现有的300公里射程拓展至600公里。布拉莫斯的第二个版本是超音波导弹。

Srinivas Channappa,studied at National Institute of Technology Karnataka,Surathkal

Russia has already pulled back on Brahmos tech transfer to India.Only fools are thinking BRAHMOS is working partnership.
Russia will not support India in future for any supersonic missile project All thanks to Feku,the uneducated RSS’cal who is licking US boots for no reason and spoiling regional peace.Feku has turned India a hate nation so much that Russia now openly supports Pakistan.
Russia is developing 2x 3x deadlier missiles than BRAHMOS with China.
Russia can also de-activate Indian BRAHMOS if they want.Highly critical technology is not yet transfered to India.India will struggle to use BRAHMOS(even existing ones)
Russia will support China in allit s military technology.Russia already pulled out of FGFA joint venture.
俄罗斯已经撤回了对印度的布拉莫斯技术转让。只有傻瓜才会认为布拉莫斯是合作项目。
俄罗斯未来不会支持印度的任何超音速导弹项目。
所有这一切都要感谢莫迪,这个没有受过教育的家伙莫名其妙地巴结美国,破坏了地区和平。莫迪把印度变成了一个充满仇恨的国家,逼得俄罗斯公开支持巴基斯坦。
俄罗斯正在与中国合作研发杀伤力比布拉莫斯导弹高2倍3倍的导弹。
俄罗斯如果下定决心,也可以让印度布拉英斯导弹变成一堆破铜烂铁。高度关键的技术还没有转移到印度。印度将难以使用布拉莫斯导弹(甚至现有的导弹)俄罗斯将全力支持中国的军事技术。俄罗斯已经退出了第五代战斗机的合作研发。

Dinesh Chandra

Hi,Well,as an Indian we’re/also I’m not in favour of anytype of war..
Cause what happens throughout a war ata We do have some very good examples..
Now.pointing out ur question if u could scroll down the answers u might have easily realise who’ll initiate war[Chinese]
PEACE TO TGE WORLD
你好,嗯,作为一个印度人,我们/我也不赞成任何形式的战争..……
因为我们清楚战争期间会发生什么
我们已经看到过一些很好的例子了.……
现在..看看你的问题,如果向下浏览一下答案,你可能会很容易意识到准会发动战争[中国人]
世界和平

Will Charlie,former Teacher at CNU(1997-2001)

every Indian thinks brahmos is everything,modi is everything.kidding yourself
每个印度人都认为布拉莫斯就是一切,莫迪无所不能,你们是来摘笑的吧。

Shantanu Pandit,Process Manager at Integrated Resources(2014-present)

India won’t do this,India never initiate any war yet,India will wait for China to to take some action or go back from Doklam,if China start hitting India with any missile than India will show them what we invent after 1962,and a little bit demo China already seen in 1967:)
印度不会这样做印度从来没有主动挑起过任何战争,印度会等着中国采取行动或从洞朗撤军,如果中国开始进攻,印度导弹将向他们展示我们在1962年后的军事发明,中国在1967年已经见识过雏形了。

Clifford Heseltine, studied History & Philosophy at University of Autodidacts

Why do we keep getting these ridiculous hypothetical “If so and so attacked/nuked/insulted so and so, what would happen?”questions?
In almost every case the entire scenario is ludicrous and there is no conceivable way the leaders of actual countries would undertake such ridiculous and potentially disastrous actions.
China has major economic deals with nations all over the world, as does India. China and India both have millions of people coming of working age every year that need productive jobs and by building factories and providing consumer goods to the world of reasonable quality at reasonable prices while giving their citizens a reasonably good quality of life they solve many internal problems.
Why in the Hell would either country go looking for external problems to complicate this workable international arrangement? Aside from instigating a war with a country that has caused them no particular heartache and also has nuclear weapons, what would be the benefit? The aggressor country would become an international pariah with their inflow of resources blockaded while their production of export goods would stop. Their economy would be in shambles overnight, and for what reason, exactly?
Come on Quorans, get a clue and stop with these ridiculous and unlikely war scenarios.
Edit:I do see that there are some ongoing border disputes between China and India, but it stilseems highly unlikely that the two most populous nations in the world would resort to all-out war and destroy both of their economies over this issue.

为什么我们总是要做荒谬的假设问题:“如果某某受到攻击/核武器攻击/侮辱某某,会发生什么?”
基本上都十分荒唐可笑,现实世界中各个国家的领导人不可能采取这种荒谬和可能的灾难性行动。
中国与世界各国都有重要的经济协议,印度也是如此。中国和印度每年都有数百万达到工作年龄的人需要生产性的工作,通过建设工厂、以合理的价格向世界提供质量合理的消费品,同时给他们的公民提供较高品质的生活,他们解决了许多国家内部问题。
为什么这两个国家要去招惹对方,自找麻烦呢?除了挑起一场跟一个没有给他们带来特别痛苦、同时拥有核武器的国家的战争,还有什么好处呢?侵略国将成为国际社会的弃儿,其资源的流入将受到封锁,而其出口商品的生产将停止。他们的经济将在一夜之间陷入混乱,究竞为了什么呢?
来吧,Quora网友们,想想吧,不要再幻想这种荒谬和不现实的战争场景。
编者按:中印之间确实存在一些边界争端,但这两个世界上人口最多的国家为了这个问题发动全面战争并摧毁两国经济的可能性仍然非常小。

Rohit Nigam,Wars interest me,they show all the shades of Humans

The BrahMos missile was primarily an anti ship missile.That’s why it’s range is about 300 KMs and it skims through the surface.
Most of the major Chinese cities are 3000+KM from the Indian borders.Hence India cannot use BrahMos on cities as such.
These missiles are deployed on the eastern border of India for defensive purposes and not for offensive.They would be used to hit the supply lines in case Chinese army makes advances.
Such tactical missiles are of little use if India plans an offensive.
布拉莫斯导弹主要就是一种反舰导弹。这就是为什么它的射程大约是300公里,而且可以低空飞行。
中国大部分主要城市距离印度边境3000多公里。因此,印度攻击城市不会使用布拉莫斯。
这些导弹部署在印度东部边界是为了防御而非进攻。它们将用于攻击补给线,阻挠中国军队的挺进速度。如果印度计划发动进攻,这种战术导弹几乎毫无用处。

Shiva Ram Gopal Mantripragada

Folks,please stay away from these sorts of silly but innocuously dangerous questions.We have been given a world to live and live peacefully to the best of our ability.There is little sense in hampering it’s continuity&existence.There has been enough bloodshed in the history of this world,in the name of religion,geographical and political boundaries.And no good has ever come out of it.Strength lies in unity and unity is all about appreciating and living harmoniously with the immense diversity of this world.I request all of you Quorans to please consider.
朋友们,请别再提这些愚套无聊的危险问题。我们生在一个和平生活的世界,应该尽我们最大的能力和平地生活。破坏和平的延续性和存在没有什么意义。在这个世界的历史长河中,已经打着宗教、地理和政治边界的旗号发生过足够多的流血事件了。结果呢,没有任何好处。团结才有力量,团结就是要欣赏、和谐地生活在这个纷繁复杂的世界上。所有的Quora网友们,请你们认真思考一下。

Danial Miraz

Like normal,they would counter-attack with nastier weapons like what every country will do.
The military production will boost 245%like US in WW2.China military will outflank Indiathrough Pakistan.China maybe bail Indian Muslims to help them.And what hurts most is many countries will cut ties with India bcoz India is the aggressor.
像往常一样,他们会用更恶毒的武器进行反击,就像每个国家都会做的那样。军火制造规模将会像二战中的美国一样增长245%。中国军队将通过巴基斯坦包抄印度。最令人痛心的是,许多国家将切断与印度的关系,因为印度是侵略者。

Jake Liu,Tech

If xx starts a war with xx,winner is always keyboard general.
如果xx和xx开战,胜者肯定都是键盘侠。

You don’t want war,believe me.Government wins,people lose.
你们不会希望爆发战争的,相信我。政府赢了,人民却承担苦果。

sam Lu

Assume that the missles can actually hit the targets,China will fight back and nuke every city India has and then it will be the end of your story.
假设导弹真的能击中目标,中国会反击,用核武器摧毁印度的每一个城市,你们的故事就完了。

Eric Li,studied at University of Electronic Science and Technology of China

The whole world will get into panic because no one knows the missiles would finally hit.It is even more horrific that they would do Brownian movement which makes them impossible to intercept.
Stop trying that!We admit your victory!
全世界都会陷入恐筛,因为没有人知道导弹最终会击中哪里。更可怕的是,他们会做布朗运动,无法被拦截。
不要试图搬弄是非!你们赢了!

Ruishen Zhang,former Associate at Deloitte(2014-2015)

I am not sure how China will react.However,I am pretty sure that India will be so screwed.
They may want to have a new New Delhi afterwards
我不确定中国会作何反应。然而,我非常肯定印度将会非常糟糕。他们可能得重建新德里了。

Jasper Budiono,Business Owner(2015-present)

mostlikely those missiles will be caught and penetrated on radar,then China will allow 1-2 missiles hit the remote area so China can begin the invasion
很有可能这些导弹会被雷达拦截并穿透,让1-2枚导弹击中中国偏远地区,这样中国就有理由入侵印度了。

Raghu Reddy Mula,works at India

Why would people ask such questions?Quora should stop deleting such questions
为什么人们会问这样的问题?Quora应该围除这样的问题

Ben Huang,former Self Employed

This is an interesting question.Maybe India can make Himalaya a little bit lower?If so,I think China will help you to make more BrahMos.
这是个有趣的问题。也许印度能把喜马拉雅山脉削低一点?如果是这样,我觉得中国会帮你们生产更多的布拉莫斯。

Yangtao Qi,B.A.from Central South University(2013)

Fight back of course!
mdansor torotheyoaronsd raihu.
If they stricke China,they will remember the year of 2017!
当然要反击!
印度人不会忘记1962年。
如果他们进攻中国,他们会铭记2017年!

May Chris  Good,points.

It only covers about 3-400 km,then Indian New Delhi will be gone as Chinese rockets or artilleries can easily reach New Delhi from Tibet as the distance between Tibet and New Delhiis about 300 to 350km.Each shot from the rockets or artillery only cost about US$10-20.
Ibelieve Chinese artillery alone will defeat the Indian’s missiles.
(note,the 400 to 450km range rockets and artilleries are developed specifically for Taiwan initially,it is no bad for China to use them in India case).
它的射程大约只有3-400公里,而中国的火箭或炮弹可以很容易地从xz击中新德里(xz和新德里之间的距离大约是300到350公里),印度的新德里将会就此消失。火箭或大炮发射的每一枚导弹只需要大约10至20美元。
我相信仅靠中国的大炮就能击败印度的导弹。
(注意,中国的400到450公里射程的火箭和火炮最初是专门为台湾研制的,如果用在印度倒也不错。

Blair Ted

China has better 5-6times super sonic missiles capable of targeting 600km targets in sea,land and air,much advanced than India’s BrahMos missiles which is the product of the Russia’s technology transfer.
However,Chinese artilleries or simple rockets would do the job against India as New Delhi is only about 350km away from Tibet.
Geographically,India is at the palm of the China’s hand.
中国拥有比印度先进5-6倍的超级音速导弹,能够在海、陆、空打击600公里范围以内的目标,射程远远超过印度的布拉莫斯导弹,布拉莫斯是俄罗斯技术转让的产物。
中国的火炮或简易火箭就足以对付印度,因为新德里距离XZ只有350公里。
从地理位置上看,印度逃不出中国的五指山。

Di Zhang,Strategy Researcher at Strategic Fooyou Agency

Sadly,we can do nothing.Although China has spent much money on developing anti-missile system,still the system cannot even catch the BrahMos missiles’trace.
As an army fun,I know that genius Indian engineers designed an amazing path planning strategy for BrahMos,which is called the Brownian Movements Path Planning Algrithm,or the BMPPA.I don’t know much how BMPPA works,but any anti-missile system in the world cannot predict the BrahMos missiles’trace,so we cannot intecept the missile.Hell no!
Chinese people love peace,please don’t do that!
迭憾的是,我们无能为力。尽管中国在发展反导系统上投入了大量资金,但反导系统甚至无法捕捉到布拉莫斯导弹的踪迹。
天才的印度工程师为布拉莫斯设计了惊人的路径规划,被称为布朗运动,或B/MPPA。我不知BMPPA是如何工作的,但是世界上任何反导弹系统都无法预测布拉莫斯导弹的轨迹,所以我们无法拦截导弹。
中国人民热爱和平,请不要这样做!

Uirehiugh louhersgioh

NUKE INDIA
核击印度。

N.Vidya Sagar Reddy,forme

Air Force Hi.…Chinese brother.…you have to mind one thing……In our history we never attack on another country.…we are peace loving people in world..Not like you
嗨..…中国兄弟…….你必须记住一件事.….在我们的历史上,我们从来没有攻击过其他国家…….我们是这个世界上出了名的爱好和平的人民..不像你们。

Kowe Kwon

i assume u r Indian.if it’s wrong,that would be my mistake,sorry,no offence.
when it coms down to this question,u can answer it by urself using ur imagination.
think about this,if Mexico strike USA with multiple missiles,what will happen?
yeah,u have got ur answer.
sorry,Mexico,no offence.
我猜你是印度人。如果说错了,那是我的错,对不起,我无意冒犯。
说到这个问题,你可以用你的想象力来回答。
想想,如果墨西哥用多枚导弹攻击美国,会发生什么?
是的,你心里肯定有答案了。
对不起,墨西哥,我无意冒犯哈。
“u can go to jungle in Uganda and play sumo with gorillas.maybe u could be a little more sober under the fierce slap by gorillas”
“你可以去乌干达的丛林里和大猩猩玩相扑。也许你在大猩程的猛击下会冷静一点。”

Rainy Guan,former Engineer

Some people,really fear the world is not chaos,do you think that China can only use the”non-
violent uncooperative”protest?Is there only India in the world with missiles?Heard of the PLA Rocket Force?
有些人真的是唯恐天下不乱,你认为中国只能用“非暴力不合作”来抗议吗?世界上只有印度拥有导弹吗?听说过中国人民解放军火箭部队吗?

Roland Wu

China will kneel down and ask for forgiveness for performing much better than India by stoping CPEP,One belt one Road project,and offer Tibet to India,those are what you expected in your dream?
please continue your dream,that will be better for you,Reality will tear up your heart.
中国俯首称臣,请求宽恕,停止CPEP,一带一路项目,把xz拱手交给印度,这都是你们所想的吧?
请继续做梦吧,做梦对你们是件好事,因为现实会撕裂你的心。

Wei Li,former Petroleum Engineer.Financial Master

We don’t worry about India missiles which are always doing”Brownian movement”.when they target Beijing.Sydney get attacked.India is the only country in this planet that spitchered their own submarine.and their battleplane crushed every day.they have crushed more than1000fighters that can arm a powerful air force.hahahah let me laugh a whilef
我们无需担心印度导弹,它们总是在做“布朗运动”。他们瞄准北京时,可能会击中悉尼,印度是这个星球上唯一一个自沉潜艇的国家。他们的战机每天都在坠毁。他们粉碎了1000多架可以武装强大空军的战斗机。

Quora User,lives in China(1998-present)

WellIndia will have a new capital in the south.
印度南部将会有一个新的首都。

Liang Xiao

Will be attacked by the Chinese army.
China’s counter weapons include:CJ-10 Range:1500 km,speed:0.75 Maher.
将会受到中国军队的攻击。
中国的反制武器包括:
CJ-10射程:1500公里,速度:0.75马赫。

CJ-20 Range:3000 km,speed:0.75 Maher.
CJ-20射程:2000英里,速度:0.75马赫。

YJ-12 Range:560 km,speed:3 Maher.
YJ-12射程:560公里,速度:3马赫。
DF-21C Range:2000 km,speed:10 Maher.
DF-21C射程:2000公里,速度:10马赫。

DF-26C Range:4000 km,speed:10 Maher.
DF-26C射程:4000公里,速度:10马赫。

DF-31A Range:12000 km,speed:12 Maher.
DF-31射程:12000公里,速度:12马赫。

JL-2Range:12000 km,speed:12 Maher.
JL-2射程:12000公里,速度:12马赫。
2000 of these missiles can be fired at any time.
以上这些导弹共有2000枚,可以随时发射。

Haiyan Chen,Native Chinese have the most real experience of China

China will use CJ10 cruise missiles and rockets with a range of more than 150 kilometers to retaliate against the attacks from India.
中国将使用射程超过150公里的CJ10巡航导弹和火箭来报复印度的袭击。

Moreover,Bula Moss missile range of about 350 kilometers,can only attack China’s westernregions,can not attack China’s big cities.But China can easily attack most India cities,including New Delhi.
So,if India really wants to invade China,then come on.
此外,布拉莫斯导弹射程约350公里,只能攻击中国西部地区,无法攻击中国的大城市。但中国可以轻易地攻击包括新德里在内的大多数印度城市。
所以,如果印度真的想侵略中国,那就尽管试试吧。

Yitian Wang,studies Biomedical Science&Medical School at Queen Mary,University of London(2020)

It is really a bad question.
When using missiles,it is declare a war.
India VS China?
Economy?Military equipment?Industrial?Education?Population?Basic facilities?Individual courage?geography influence?r’m sory that India have nothing to fight a war with China,at least now.
So,it’impossible to happen conflict like that.
By the way,it is a serious problem that Indian missiles can do”Brownian movement”.
Wish we Chinese can keep peace and harmony with Indians for always.
这真是个糟糕的问题。使用导弹就是宣战。
中国跟印度比?
经济?军事装备工业?教育人口?基本设施?士气?地理地位?我很抱歉,印度无法凭借任何一项来跟中国开战,至少现在还没有。
所以,像这样的冲突是不可能发生的。
顺便说一句,印度导弹能不能做“布朗运动”还是一个大问题。
希望我们中国人能永远与印度人保持和平与和谐。

相关推荐:军事/印度