中国文件浮出水面,洞悉解放军如何解读印度人的战略思想!印度网民:哇塞,中国人似乎比我们都更相信自己的战略能力

2021.11.15 发布在 世界看中国 栏目

中国文件浮出水面,洞悉解放军如何解读印度人的战略思想!印度网民:哇塞,中国人似乎比我们都更相信自己的战略能力 世界看中国-第1张

Fascinating Chinese document surfaces,with insights into how PLA reads Indian strategic mind
中国文件浮出水面,洞悉解放军如何解读印度人的战略思想
China Aerospace Studies Institute in America has recently translated a PLA document,outlining its long-term military and strategic outlook,into English.Such a document is produced in China only once in about 13 years.In episode 682 of#CutTheClutter,Shekhar Gupta picks up parts of the document that talk about India,and uses this unique opportunity to look at India from the lens of its biggest adversary.
美国的中国航天研究院最近将中国人民解放军的一份文件翻译成英文,概述了其长期军事和战略前景。这样的文件在中国大约13年才出现一次。在文件的第682集,谢卡尔古普塔(Shekhar Gupta)挑选了文件中有关印度的部分内容,并利用这个独特的机会从印度最大对手的角度来看待印度。

以下是youtube上印度网民的评论:

archon1410

China doesn’t want India to develop it’s navy and gain the ability to block Mcca Strait through the Andn and Nicobar archipelago.
中国不希望印度发展海军,不希望印度海军具备通过安达曼和尼科巴群岛来封锁马六甲海峡的能力

aashish1703

I’m surprised to see how well the chinese analysed India.We need such brains who can do pn analysis logically without getting emotive.I hope we get to see such work from our strategists.
中国人对印度的分析真是透彻。我们需要这样的人才。我希望能看到印度也有如此优秀的战略家出来担当此大任

ndhu P Prasad

Chinese are not fools like Pakistani are,other wise they won’t be what they are now.So Indians need to con trate more on Chinese
中国人不像巴基斯人那样愚蠢,否则也不会有今天发达的中国。
印度人应该更多地研究中国人

Mukesh Angrish

The Chinese came to Ladakh because they wanted to divert our naval resources to the army.
India is building defence sorts and airports in Andn and Nicobar islands.These would make it a lot easier for India to block the Mca Strait in an event of war.Such an advantage could cripple the Chinese economy since more than 70%of China’s power resources come through these narrows.It is also the reason why China is heavily investinq in the Arctic ship routes.
中国人在拉达克挑事,是为了让我们把资源投入到陆军上。
目前,印度正在安达曼和尼科巴群岛建设国防海港和机场。建成后,印度在发生战争时更容易封锁马六甲海峡
这样的优势,使得印度能打击中国经济,因为中国70%以上的能源运输都要经过马六甲海峡。这也是中国大力投资北极航道的原因

Jayanta Chakrabarty

Thanks.It was pretty good analysis of the thought-reading of the Chinese.
很好,深入解读了中国人的思维过程

jashan sandhu

India has played it’s cards well with courage and clarity of thought and action
印度凭借勇气、清晰的思想和犀利的行动,打好了自己的牌

YAZ1 77

We started reading Sun Tzu and they started reading Chanakya Nitti.
By the end of this Cold War we would be speaking Mandarin and they would be speaking Hindi.
我们开始研究孙子兵法,他们开始参透查那迦尼提。冷战结束后,我们会说普通话,而他们会说印地语

Soumyadip Mukhopadhyay

I tried dearning Madain.That’s damn tough dude…
Indo Aryan languages are far easier to learn
我在学中文。该死的,这也太难了,伙计。印度雅利安语学起来要容易得多

Just Wonder

Wrong.China doesn’t even care to study india.Their goal is how to surpass U.S.India is not in their sight.
错,中国不怎么在乎印度。他们的目标是如何超越美国,印度不在他们的视线之内啊

kiran Pappu

But,they made us feel like a strong opponent which reminds me of second chapter of Sunzi
“Make your enemy feel stronger than you and attack him with surprise.Give a thought.
他们给我们的感觉就是,对方是一个强大的对手,这让我想起了《孙子兵法》第二章“让敌人觉得对手比自己强,然后出其不意地攻击他”

Rajesh Daviyal

I genuinely like listening to Army chiefs.So much professionalism to learn from them.
我真的很喜欢听印度陆军将领们的讲话。我想向他们学专业知识

vamsi krishna

First I thought,how the Chinese know about us in such depth.
Then I realized with corrupt bureaucracy all these decades how easy it is to get this information.
首先我想啊,中国人怎么对我们了解得这么深啊。然后我意识到,在印度腐败的作风下,中国获取这些信息其实很容易

Goutam Majumder

Excellent decluttering today.Now it is almost clear why the Chinese caused trouble in Ladakh last year.
我真是豁然开朗啊。现在我知道为什么中国人去年要在拉达克给我们制造麻烦了

Alice w

Except it was Indian soldiers who started it first.
其实是印度士兵先挑起事端的

Sankalp

All warfare is based on deception-Sun Tzu
孙子兵法:兵不厌诈

Shashank Tripathi

The Biggest Challenge we have is the 0.5 front we have inside the country.
我们面临最大的挑战是国内0.5线的内部敌人

Momo bhai

its called opposition…an essential part of de acy
你是说那些反对派吧,这是民主的必要组成部分啊

legend Saho

We are not agressive on all of our international border whether it’s Pakistan or China,we wait for them to take action this has what costed us everytime.
无论是面对巴基斯坦还是中国,我们在处理边界争端时不具有侵略性,而是被动等待他们采取行动,这让我们每次都付出了代价。

shivendra mishra

China:knows A to Z about india.
Meanwhile India:still can’t fiqure out why China broke an almost war out of nowhere
中国对印度的一切都了如指掌啊
而印度仍然不明白为何中国要突然挑起战争

Amit

India has recently started China Studies.I think recently External Affairs Minister talked in China Studies seminar in IIT Madras.
印度最近开始研究中国。我记得外交部长最近在马德拉斯印度理工学院的中国研究研讨会上讲了话

Niraj Paul

@Vishwak Chandra they got agressive because of Infrastructure development in Border areas and I think before 2024 ion Army gonna do something big if Economy got revive may be Pangong till Finger 8 capture
他们仗着边界基础设施好,才对我们咄咄逼人的。
我认为在2024年选举之前,如果经济复苏,印度军队会有大动作的,可能会占领班公湖,并一直占领8号手指地区

manoj kumar

I know they r goin to do something.lts our strategic security forces slee
我知道他们要采取行动,而我们的战略安全部队在沉睡

Aditya Pati

@manoi kumar I don’t think so we don’t know much deep in our countries strategy
非也非也,我们对自己国家的战略了解不多啊

ky Finger

Who told you we don’t do,almost 90%of India’s defense and strategic policies are classified and we only see a surface level discussions in public sphere
谁说的。印度国防和战略政策90%都是机密的,我们只在公共场合才能看到表面上的讨论

Laxmi Kanth

Do u think a country like India surrounded by various adversaries dont study them?You are fool
周围敌人环视,你觉得印度不会研究那些国家吗?
你就是笨蛋

Paban Snta

Bro if china knows everything about us,how did china fail to capture southern bank of pangong lake?
既然中国对我们了如指掌,为何中国没有夺取班公湖的南岸呢

manoj kumar

@Paban Snta capturing is not its intention
他们并没有打算夺取班公湖南岸啊

Kabang Dai

@Vishwak Chandra once the world acknowledqe china as super power if will already become a hyper power.
china is not just a regional it is already a super power.the only difference between USA and china is that china intentionally don’t upgrade their military like US because they want to first dominate economically and uplift Thier whole population into middle class..they already excelled US in terms of research paper,patent filed,6G n communication tech,green energy tech,maglev and construction tech,Al,automation,industrial tech and many other sectors…
一旦世界承认中国是超级大国,中国就已经是超级大国。中国不仅仅是一个地区大国,而且是一个全球性的超级大国。美国和中国之间的唯一区别是,中国不会像美国那样在军事上投入巨资,而是努力发展经济,让国民都进入中产阶级行列。他们已经在研究论文、专利申请、6G通信技术、绿色能源技术、磁悬浮和建筑技术、人工智能、自动化、工业技术和许多其他领域超过了美国。

Paban Snta

@manoj kumar it is very difficult for a common people to predict or speak military strategies.
China won a war aq inst russia,does not mean china knows everything.If china knows everything,why did it fail in china-vietnam war?
普通人很难预测军事策略。中国赢得了对俄罗斯的战争,并不意味着中国知道一切。如果中国什么都知道,为什么中越战争打输了

Kabang Dai

@V Kumar western medias have been predicting since 1960s that china will col pse within 20 years….again in 1980 and and still saying..but they became stronger…everyone said chinese company will col pse becaus elf covid and they came out stronger than ever.
西方媒体从20世纪60年代就开始预测中国将在20年内,到了1980年,他们还在说。可是中国越来越强大。每个人都说中国公司会因为新冠疫情而纷纷倒闭,而他们却比以前更强大。

chandra mouli

Thank you so much china.You made us to realize that we are strong and sure we can teach you a lesson in future for sure san
谢谢中国。你让我们发现自己是强大的,我们肯定会在未来给你们一个教训的

Dev.o1

Chinese strategist have done a phenomenal job,of fiquring us out,still l wonder how long will take for Indian strategists to fiqure chinese mindset.or would we wait for USA to do it for usm
中国战略家真的把我们印度人研究透了啊,我想知道印度战略家要花多长时间才能搞清楚中国人的心态。还是说我们准备让美国人代劳

Prog Adkri

Wow!It seems the Chinese have greater fa th in our strategic capabilities than anyone among us
哇塞,中国人似乎比我们都更相信自己的战略能力

Tony

China act strategically to maintain peace whereas India over-estimated itself,and reacted emotionally and negatively
中国的战略行动是为了维护和平,而印度高估了自己,做出了情绪化和消极的反应