为什么苏联倒下了,而中国能一直繁荣下去?印网民:中国综合了美国和苏联的优势,中国更复杂

2021.11.18 发布在 世界看中国 栏目

为什么苏联倒下了,而中国能一直繁荣下去?印网民:中国综合了美国和苏联的优势,中国更复杂 世界看中国-第1张

Why USSR col psed and China is still flourishing despite having similar ideologies?UPSC History
意识形态相同,为什么苏联倒下了,而中国能一直繁荣下去?

以下是youtube网友的评论:

Soumyabrata Karmakar

In a single line:money runs the world.If you are rich,you will be hailed by every one
一句话:金钱主宰这个世界。如果你富有,每个人都会向你欢呼

No Namer

They are playing by Brain and we are playing with emotion
他们是在用大脑玩游戏,而我们是在用情感玩游戏

Mr UNKNOWN

This proves that Small difference can make big changes
这证明了小的差异可以带来大的变化

Aryan Rajak

Small and steady changes makes huge differen
微小的变化不断累积,会带来巨大的变化。

Rajyada maini

Because chinese civilisation has alwavs flourished with strong centralised foundational structure and whenever it tries to liberalise it has gotten into a chaos-like 1949 chinese civil war.
因为中国文明总是在强大的中央基础结构下繁荣发展的,一旦自由化,就会陷入混乱,就像1949年中国内战一样。

Ashley silver

Because USSR had separate states with state go nn m ents and China had all provinces under the centres control
因为苏联是有各个独立的加盟共和国组成的,而中国的所有省份都在中央控制之下

Nitin Jadhav

Wonderful topic,presentation and analysis.
这个话题好,分析得好

Shinchando

Imagine being Magnolia…sandwiched between two big nations..
想象一下蒙古,夹在两个大国之间

the boy

Mongolia was satalite state of ussr
蒙古是苏联的卫国

lam Siva

This is why I fear India’s col pse.Till now India is united but Indians are not.
这就是为什么我担心印度会。到目前为止,印度这个国家是统一的,但印度人不团结

gen tech21

We can say China is the improved version of Soviet…
我们可以说中国是苏联的改良版。

Overlord Born

Just do google about Qing Dynasty map,it was the last dynasty of china which lasted until 1644-1912 and you should be aware that china is a 5000 years long continuous civilization.
Just like how india cms territory because of British colonial India but china does it because of their own long dynasty who had always controlled those areas.
可以上网搜索下清朝的地图,清朝是中国最后一个王朝,时间跨度是1644年-1912年,你应该知道中国是一个持续5000年的文明。英国殖民印度,版图扩大了,现在印度也说这些领土都是印度的。中国也是这么做,以前的封建王朝控制了哪些地区,中国也说那些领士是中国自古以来的领土。

Vivek Saxena

China is mix of USA and Russia,China is more complex
中国综合了美国和苏联的优势,是美国和苏联的混合体,中国更复杂

Faizan Hasan

Now china is the richest country in the world
如今,中国已经是世界上最富裕的国家

Mayank Uniya

This is very true that china is not like usse but china is more more powerful then ussr
确实啊,中国不是苏联,而是比苏联要强大得多

Ripnjoy Sky

The chinese state always lived under some kind of dic ship in the same geographical location for many millenia.As a matter of fact,even Japan can easily survive and prosper under rule if economic policies are well planned like china.
几千年以来,中国这个国家一直是中央的。
如果经济政策像中国一样规划良好,就连日本在这种体制下也可以繁荣起来的

Prakhar Tiwar

The only reason China has not only sustained but grown economically is because of free-markets and globalisation,which has increased the economic strength of China
中国经济持续增长,得益于自由市场和全球化,这增强了中国的经济实力

Anita singh

I don’t think any of the Chinese empire established by Chinese was as large as present day China
以前的中华帝国,没有当今中国的版图那么大吧

Ripnjoy Sky

@Anita singh it was not that large but many of those areas like Tib were thinly populated ano generally lived under the suzereianity of the chinese empire.We must remember that the chinese soceity was always ruled with a iron hand and as such,neighbouring kingdoms were merely vassals of the chinese empire.It’s not like in India were multiple kingdoms held the seat of power.
是没有那么大。不过西藏等这些人口稀少的地区,他们的宗主国是中华帝国。
记住,很多周边王国其实是中华帝国的附属国。
不像在印度,多个王国同时存在

Overlord Born

Then you should learn about tang Dynasty and their
1ast empire Qing Dynasty which has largest territory and lasted till 1912..
然后你应该了解唐朝和他们的最后一个帝国清朝,版图幅员辽阔,一直持续到1912年清朝灭亡。

Tripathi J

Putin-The new Tsar
普京是新的沙皇

Navdeep Singh

Sir l wanted to learn about co unist country and you made it thank you sir.
我刚好想了解共产主义回家,就看到了这个,谢謝

Puritan Templar

China overtook USA in terms of wealth,saw yesterday news
昨天的新闻说,中国的财富已经超过美国了

Adi Chauhan

@Puritan Templar per capita matters!!
要看人均

PEATSAHEADSHOT

@Adi Chauhan gdp matters
要看GDP

SAITAMA

@Adi Chauhan per capita doesn’t matter if wealth is in the hands of few.
如果财富掌握在少数人手中,人均并不重要。

Pretesh dbritto

but we missed our old friend(USSR)
我们怀念我们的老朋友(前苏联)啊

CHANDU IB

Friend?
是老朋友?

Cauliflower

wow,you really have a good voice and good knowledge of history
哇,历史知识也很丰富

Rishab KS

China has adopted capi ism that’s why it survived.
中国接受了资本主义,这就是中国能繁荣下去的原因

Arijit Patra

Well expned
说得很好

Sri Rathin

Please Meke more&more expose Videos about China
以后可以多制作一些介绍中国的视频

Chekk Raj Kumar

Finally,China peacefully Developed country
最后,中国是爱好和平的发达国家

EE E

No,And debatable
不,这点值得商榷

Be Calm

Economic liberalisation simple
经济自由化,就这么简单

AVARTAN

Soviets helps their alies to develop steel plants,dams,schools etc
苏联帮助他们的盟友发展钢铁厂、水坝、学校等

Chitrajit Mondal

This was awesome
真棒

Slow

Please make video of Best Indian state in India and give them Rankings
能不能说一下印度哪个邦最好,给印度各邦排下名吧

ROHAN AGARWAL

How Mongolia saved itself from com
蒙古是如何做到不被吞井的

EE E

Because there is nothing,except horse and grass
因为蒙古啥都没有啊,除了马和草原,哈都没有

P101 Pana

By the way Russia’s gdp per capita is same as that of China.People make titles in a way as if Russia is ultra poor country and China is super rich whereas the reality is both are Middle income countries miles away from being a developed country.
顺便说一下,俄罗斯的人均gdp和中国一样高。你们这样说,搞得好像俄罗斯这个国家很穷而中国很富裕一样似的,然而事实上,两个国家都是中等收入国家,离发达国家还差得很远。

KARMANATOR JANGPANGI

Both the countries choose the same goal for a longer plan but one used offence and other used economy.Nice strategy here!
两国选择了相同的目标,但一个行为不当,另一个经济发展得很好。策略不错

TITAS SAMANTA

Tsarist Russia also included Ukraine,Moldova and Central Asian states,
沙俄还包括乌克兰、摩尔多瓦和中亚国家

Jumbomuffin 13

USSR fell because ww2,Cold War,etc etc
前苏联是因为打了二战、后来又美苏冷战,才倒下的

kkk

and big military
还有就是军队规模过于庞大

16 Rajesh Gupte

very important topic
这个话题很重要

WORLD INFORMATION CHANNEL

Soviet col pse due to influence of usa and western nations soviet was very great and it has own culture
China is world old civilization and it has own identity different than western.people of china very well know and peoples of china control over whole china but china open its economy in 1979 and incress his strenath after few vear later china join wto and it was great results after 2000.Today china give autonomy in various field but control over also present simatenoues.
苏联的是美国和西方国家造成的,苏联非常伟大,有自己的文化
中国是世界文明古国,有自己不同于西方的特性。中国人非常了解自己国家,中国人控制着自己国家,中国在1979年开放了经济
2000年以后,中国加入了WTO,取得了巨大的成就。今天,中国在各个领域自给自足

Sreehari Nandu

Soviet Union was influential enough to face the geopo itical threat of USA.They col psed due to a fallacious economic model that heavily relied on centralised economic decisons.
苏联的影响力足以对抗美国的地缘政治威胁。苏联的是由于严重依赖中央经济决策的错误经济模式造成的

VISHAL SINGH

Soviet was way ahead of us in terms of technology,space research they were very powerful and tough competitor to mighty usa n the other hand cold didn’t even started china economy is slowing,real estate was in huge det
苏联的技术和太空实力远远领先于美国,他们是美国强有力的竞争对手,另一方面,中国经济正在放缓,房地产负债累累